The grey area between wear-and-tear and damage is difficult to navigate for renters, owners, and property managers when it comes to deciphering who is responsible for the cost of repair or replacement.
What is wear and tear?
Generally speaking, the definition of wear and tear is when something has deteriorated in a rental property due to regular use or impact over time. This is based on normal daily use and can be assessed as a gradual degradation over time.
Related Articles
What is depreciation at a rental property?
Hot tips for property investors at tax time
Who is responsible for cleaning gutters at a rental property?
Meet Lily Thompson Neilson Partners Business Development Manager
What about floor coverings?
Where floor coverings are concerned, obvious things like large stains, burn marks, or scratches that weren’t there before are easily handled as part of the condition report. But things that are difficult to document across the course of a long tenancy, like the impact of a rolling office chair, or a fluffy smelly dog on an isolated patch of carpet are more tenuous.
What would be considered reasonable wear and tear to one renter, investor, or property manager, could be seen as damage by another – not to mention varying VCAT member opinions.
What steps are taken to reach an agreement?
In every case, the default first step is to refer back to the original condition report. Ideally, the condition of the carpet today should mostly match the photos taken at the commencement of the rental agreement.
A large, significant stain (or numerous stains) that were not evident in any of the photos from before, would generally be deemed outside the definition of wear and tear and the owner should be able to claim for it to be attended to.
Depreciation at a rental property
It is not always that straightforward. Depreciation is a key factor in making decisions around wear and tear also. Generally, a carpet's shelf life in terms of depreciation is about 8-10 years. After this time, it is no longer considered an asset, and claims on its value can no longer be made. Investors claim depreciation of an item each year within their tax returns (or should be), so at the end of that 8-10 year period, the carpet is effectively worth nothing.
How can you claim compensation for something that has no monetary value?
So, if for example, a renter accidentally spills hot candle wax on a 12-month-old carpet, the outcomes around repair or replacement could be quite different from the same accident occurring on an 11-year-old carpet. You’re far less entitled to claim a portion of the renters bond to repair a small section of damage to a 12-year-old carpet than you would be if it still had a considerable amount of time left in its shelf life. If the renter has lived with old carpet for some time (that you’ve not been inclined to replace) and/or you intend to replace the carpet sometime in the near future, it may be better to consider negotiation and split the difference.
Learn more about depreciation at a rental property here.
Listen to the experts
We encourage property owners to always follow the lead of their First National Real Estate Neilson Partners property manager when it comes to making these decisions.
Our property managers have seen hectares of carpet in their careers and are trained to give our investors good advice when it comes to maintaining your property and increasing its rental value.
